TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT AND SERVICE DELIVERY OF SMALL AUDIT FIRMS IN NIGERIA

Abstract

The project examines the evaluation of total quality management and service delivery of small audit firms in Nigeria. It emphasizes on the development of team success through the implementation of total quality management practice resulting to credible output to satisfy the various users of the financial statement upon which, the auditor’s opinion is relied on. The primary source of data collection was employed in this study in which questionnaire and personal interview were used. The findings revealed that total quality management practice is a continuous work process starting with customer/client requirement and expectations and ending with their satisfaction. It is concluded that continuous improvement process toward predictable degree of uniformity and dependability which must involve all firms personnel. The study recommends that teamwork establishment and improvement on process planning that focuses attention on customer’s relationship.     

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Title Page                                                                 i

Certification                                                     ii     

Dedication                                                       iii    

Acknowledgments                                            iv    

Abstract                                                           v     

Table of Contents                                             vi    

Chapter One: Introduction                                   

1.1   Background to the Study                                         1     

1.2   Statement of Problem                                      3     

1.3   Research Questions                                                 3     

1.4   Objectives of the Study                                    4     

1.5   Statement of Hypotheses                                 5     

1.6   Significance of the Study                                         7     

1.7   Scope of the Study                                           7     

1.8   Limitations of the Study                                  8     

1.9   Definition of Terms                                          8     

Chapter Two: Review of Related Literature         

2.1   Introduction                                                     10   

2.2   Total Quality Management Practice (TQM)               10

2.3   Benefit of Total Quality Management Practice 12

2.4   Audit firms and its services                             13

2.5   The implementation TQM in small audit firms        16

2.6   Objectives of Total Quality Management          20

Chapter Three: Research Method and Design      

3.1   Introduction                                                     22   

3.2   Research design                                               22   

3.3   Description of the Population of the Study              22   

3.4   Sample Size                                                     23   

3.5   Sampling Techniques                                      23   

3.6   Sources of Data Collection                               23   

3.7   Method of data Presentation                            24   

3.8   Method of Data Analysis                                  24   

Chapter Four: Data Presentation, Analysis

and Interpretation                                                

4.1   Introduction                                                     27   

4.2   Presentation of Data                                        27   

4.3   Data Analysis                                                   27   

4.4   Testing of Hypothesis                                       44   

Chapter Five: Summary of Findings, Conclusion

 and Recommendations                                        

5.1   Introduction                                                     51   

5.2   Summary of Findings                                      52   

5.3   Conclusion                                                      53   

5.4   Recommendation                                             54   

References                                                       56   

Appendix A                                                      58   

Appendix B                                                      59   

CHAPTER ONE

INTRODUCTION

1. Background to the Study

Total Quality Management (TQM) practices and small audit firm’s services delivery have had accounting antecedence. However, the concept can be traced back to the early 1920 production control ideal notably, the concept developed in the 1940s and 1950s by some Americans gurus in the likes of Deming, Juran and Feigenbaum.   

The concept, has many definitions worked upon by quality management discipline such as Deming, Juran, Crosby, Ishikawa and Feigenbaum who defined the concept in various ways but the essence and spirit remained unchanged. Furthermore, the definition of quality have changed with the passage of time, with changing customer/client’s need nad requirements but the essence has more or less been able to develop an approach to problem solving and conformation to standard for customer’s satisfaction (Vindu & Himanshu, 2007).

An audit consists of a methodical review and objective examination of an enterprise financial statement which includes the process of verification of specific information as determined by the auditor of or established practice. The purpose of an audit is to express an opinion as to whether or not the statement of account presents a true and fair view whatever it purports to report and to report accordingly (Conviser & Duffy, 2006).

Distinctively, total quality management (TQM) practices and small audit firms services delivery are crucial in the economy in the sense that, shareholder requires the services of audit firms by appointing auditors to lend credibility to the financial statement. A lot of people are interested in the financial statements of companies for one reason or the other.

The users are refer to as stakeholders and they include shareholders (actual and potential), lenders (e.g. banks), employees, suppliers, customers government etc (Odion & Lawani, 2009). These users and indeed the general public sees the financial disclosures as the end result. Nevertheless, this has agitated both the managers and employees with increased responsibilities to ensure increased quality management and services delivery in small audit firms.

The focus of this study is to determine total quality management practice and services delivery in small audit firms in Nigeria.

1. Statement of Problem

Total Quality Management (TQM) practice and small audit services delivery by quality service delivery which comes from inspired management team, employees and managers at all level look up to executive in small audit firms to set an example and a tune for the rest of the firms.

1. Research Questions

If total quality management practices can not provide accurate and sound audit services, what else could? In view of this, the study attempt to address the following;

1. Does total quality management practices ensure continuous improvement process in small audit firms?
2. Is a total quality management practice responsible for the objectiveness and effectiveness of small audit firms?
3. Is the concept of total quality management practice used in detecting or eradicating weakness in small audit firms
4. Does total quality management practice reflects a true picture of how small audit firms need operate. 
   1. Objectives of the Study

It is impossible for an audit firm to produce outstanding services unless its top managers engages in Total Quality Management (TQM) practices. Total quality management practices arouses the understanding of group success. Personal success is derived from group success and its credit must be distributed among the team members. Hence, this research set to satisfy the following objectives;

1. To find out if there is total quality management practices ensures continuous improvement process in small audit firms.
2. To ascertain if total quality management practices is responsible for the objectiveness and effectiveness of small audit firms.
3. To find out if the concept of total quality management practice is used in detecting or eradicating weakness in small audit firms
4. To find out if total quality management practice reflects a true picture of how small audit firms need operate. 
   1. Statement of Hypotheses

The hypothesis of this research is divided into two. They are known as the null hypothesis (HO) and the alternative hypothesis (HI).

In this study, four hypotheses were formulated and are to be tested. The hypotheses are listed as below;

Hypothesis One

HO:   Total quality management practice does not ensure continuous improvement process in small audit firms.     

HI:    Total quality management ensures continuous improvement process in small audit firms.

Hypothesis Two

HO:   Total quality management practice is not responsible for the objectiveness and effectiveness of small audit firms.

HI:    Total quality management practice is responsible for the objectiveness and effectiveness of small audit firms.

Hypothesis Three

HO:   The concept of total quality management practice is not used in detecting or eradicating weakness in small audit firms in Nigeria.

HI:    The concept of total quality management practice is used in detecting or eradicating weakness in small audit firms in Nigeria.

Hypothesis Four

HO:   Total quality management practice does not reflect a true picture of how small audit firms need to operate.

HI:    Total quality management practices reflect a true picture of how small audit firms need to operate.

1. Significance of the Study

The significance of this study is to ascertain the dynamics of total quality management practices and services delivery in small audit firms overall performance. 

Information derived from this study will be of great benefits to the following members of the society;

1. Researcher: The study will serve as an existing literature for future researchers.
2. Firm: This study will provide a basis to audit firm so as to appreciate total quality management practice.
   1. Scope of the Study

The study is to cover audit firms with less than ten staffs, owned by three or less entrepreneurs and with a capital base of less than ten million naira (N10,000,000) and that have adopted Total Quality Management (TQM) practices in its organization. The study practically took place in Nigeria with more emphasis in Benin City firms and was within the range of eight (8) years (2005 – 2013). A sample size of 85 was used for effective survey.   

1. Limitations of the Study

Total quality management practices are difficult to achieve as a result of its technicality. It is also, sometimes unrealistic and unattainable in many aspects and so many organization contexts.

The research design survey has a limitation that some respondents were unavailable to give responses. The questionnaire research instrument has the limitation that its structured nature may compel some respondents to provide answers that they do not fully endorse. There were also the limitation of scarcity of materials needed and money resources.    

1. Definition of Terms

Audit: The auditing practice (APB) in the UK defined an audit as an exercise whose objective is to enable auditors to express an opinion whether the financial statements give a true and fair way (or equivalent) of the entity’s affairs at the period and of its profit or loss (or income and expenditure) for the period ended have been properly prepared in accordance with the applicable reporting framework (for example, relevant legislation and applicable accounting standards) or, where statutory or other specific requirements prescribed the term “present fairly” (Odion & Lawani, 2009).

Auditing Services: The American Accounting Association (AAA) Committee defines auditing as a systematic process of objectively obtaining and evaluating evidence regarding assertions about economic actions and events to ascertain the degree of correspondence between the assertions and established criteria and communicating the results to interested users (Odion & Lawani, 2009).

Audit Terms: According to Coviser and Druffy (2006), audit firms are group of enterprise that has legal power to carry out audit services for business enterprise.